In defense of egalitarian mining

12 March 2019
This entry is from March 2019, more than seven years ago, and parts of it may be out of date.

While I can understand the purely technical arguments in favor of adopting ASICs, to me it seems dangerous to treat Monero as a tool where the mining process doesn't have any kind of social implication -- and for some reason nobody seems to discuss these implications. As already stated, the fact that Monero is anti-ASIC is not pettiness, it is part of the core of the project and there is a specific reason for this: egalitarian mining.

How long have we been fighting ASICs? As far as I know, it hasn't even been 2 years since we've been doing research on PoW and forking to avoid them. Is that long enough for us to simply abandon this feature and accept that Monero mining will be provided by a select group of manufacturers, in which the logistics and distribution process is very far from the availability of CPUs and GPUs worldwide?

Today our stance is that the money of this protocol can be printed by anyone who has a computer or graphics card. Regardless of the physical location of this person. He/she does not need to ask permission from anyone, from any manufacturer, from any government. Nobody even needs to know that this person is printing money. He/she can do it anonymously. That in my view is an integral part of the protocol.

And I repeat, I understand the pro-ASIC arguments, but I have my doubts about abandoning that battle so, so quickly, only because we are currently failing.

How long will it take for governments to require ASIC manufacturers to have special permits? How long will it take for everyone who buys ASICs to be on a special list, classified as "people capable of printing money"? How long do you think it will take for the mining process to be completely controlled by a few entities? Perhaps decentralized enough not to allow a 51% attack on the network, but is this the ONLY attack we should defend ourselves against?

Perhaps most of the people involved in a more advanced and technical level of the protocol (like the people commenting here) live in countries or regions where there is no need to worry about this type of limitation. Perhaps the majority here need not worry about the absurd logistical problems involved in importing ASICs into countries that are not classified as "first world". Perhaps these people don't deserve to participate in the mining process.

I also understand the argument that if Monero becomes extremely valuable, even if it is resistant to ASICs, the network will have too high a difficulty for a person with a consumer-grade computer to really make money. I understand this argument, but I don't accept it so easily.

There are two reasons why I believe that this argument is not good enough: the first is that there are millions of people living with less than $1 per day, and maybe, for these people, making "a few dollars" a month can make a difference. Whole communities could pool-mine and keep the money inside their local community. The second is that this argument completely ignores the existence of thousands of small and medium-sized businesses around the world that have half a dozen computers and one or two servers. This opens a very important path of profitability for many people on the planet. In a society educated about blockchain and mining, most of these companies could increase their profitability by using 20% (or any other optimized value) of desktop and server processing to mine Monero during business hours -- and even during idle times if electricity is cheap or subsidized. Perhaps this is not worth fighting for.

The moment we accept defeat in the war against ASICs, we are accepting that Monero becomes a network on which, to participate in the process of printing money, you will need to ask permission. I particularly don't like this. I don't want to ask anyone for permission. But I will have no other option if it becomes the case.

Anyway, I write this just to remind decision makers that there are implications that go beyond the technological details of the protocol. I will not pretend to have a perfect solution to this problem, because I do not have one, but it discourages me to see that, in my opinion, some people are eager to abandon this war without really exploring all viable alternatives.

And if, in the end, we really lose this war, then fine. But I'd like us to fight more against that centralizing power before simply assuming it's useless.

ASICs are not accessible for everyone

I like Monero. A lot. But I don't think this project is so big that it has single-handedly destroyed the whole ASICs manufacturing industry with its 6-months scheduled fork, as some of the pro-ASIC users here tend to believe.

If you're one of the people who can't understand why Monero strives to be ASIC resistant, let me share one of the few reasons.

I find it amazing that I have to explain this to people. Not only is the manufacture of ASICs for cryptocurrency mining extremely centralized, but they're not even accessible to most of the world.

You don't even need to look that far, just see how Bitcoin mining works. ASICs still are not widely available and no one is threatening to change Bitcoin's mining algorithm. Unless you live in the US or another country considered "first world", ASICs are virtually unavailable to you. I know that in Brazil if you want an old-ish ASIC you will need to buy it second hand from a sketchy dude on Brazil's version of eBay for probably 5x the normal price. Or you can import from China and pay so much in shipping and customs that it becomes absurdly expensive, in a way that only very, very rich people can afford them.

But guess what? GPUs and CPUs are widely available in any local shop. Pretty much anywhere in the world. I'm sure people in Zimbabwe and Venezuela can buy CPUs and GPUs, but I don't think they have easy access to Bitcoin ASICs.

My bet is that people can't understand this point because 99% of Reddit's traffic is from the US and you don't have this kind of problem over there.

"But bitlamas, if we don't let ASICs mine in the network how can they become commoditized?"

Monero is probably the only major cryptocurrency project that strives to be ASIC-resistant. The manufacturers can still work on ASICs for many other cryptocurrencies, like Bitcoin, Litecoin, Dash, ZCash, Grin, Ethereum, etc. They're not commoditized for these algorithms, so what makes you think they will instantly become so for CryptoNight?

The reasonable way to go forward would be to wait until they become widely available for one of the existing algorithms and THEN it would make sense to embrace ASICs and fork to that algo. It's not like Monero is so big that it can absolutely destroy manufacturers, lol.

"But GPU manufacture is also centralized! AMD and Nvidia vastly dominate the market. Checkmate, loser."

Not only can the hardware be used for different things, but these companies hardly behave the same way as ASIC companies do. I'll quote u/obit33 on that.

GPU-companies don't behave the way ASIC-companies do. GPU's are fare more widespread and everyone can buy one. GPU-copanies haven't been caught first using their GPU's for own profit and then selling them to the wider public when they themselves are in possession of a next generation gpu...

And just the fact that you can buy a GPU anywhere in the world is already a major advantage over ASICs. So this argument kinda sucks. And CPU mining is also available so people/companies can finally monetize their idle servers.

All in all, ASIC mining is a small industry without any incentive to sell the highest quality hardware to the public, where only a few people can play the game because of the huge barrier of entry that it creates. It concretely centralizes mining, so why the hell would we go that way?

If ASIC mining is so important right now, the market can signal it and people will flock to another competitor of the project, or even stay on the 0.13 version of Monero. If we, who don't want ASICs right now, are all wrong, then the market can dump the hell out of Monero and support something else.

References

  1. ^ bitlamas, comment of 12 March 2019 on “Schedule meeting to discuss the future of the PoW algorithm”, monero-project/meta, issue 315.
Retrieved from https://gatti.sh/log/egalitarian-mining